Same photo, two different lay outs

I've been playing around with two photos of Mia I took at a soccer game when she was upset with her Momma. I did two completely different style layouts with the photos. Can't believe the difference in the two. One is kind of sweet and the other is grungey. I personally think I like the grungey one better. What do you think?

Supplies used were:

1. Nicole Young's "Retro Jive Girl"
2. Robin Gough's "Urban Myths" kit

Both kits are available at Digital Scrapbook Place.